
William Jayne
Years in office: 1861-1863 |

Newton Edmunds
Years in office: 1863-1866 |

Andrew J. Faulk
Years in office: 1866-1869 |

John A. Burbank
Years in office: 1869-1873 |

John L. Pennington
Years in office: 1874-1878 |

William A. Howard
Years in office: 1878-1880 |

Nehemiah G. Ordway
Years in office: 1880-1884 |

Gilbert A. Pierce
Years in office: 1884-1887 |

Louis K. Church
Years in office: 1887-1889 |

Arthur Calvin Mellette
Years in office: March 11, 1889-October 1, 1889 |